Bulletin of Experimental Treatments for AIDS (BETA), published by the San Francisco AIDS Foundation, is one of the most comprehensive HIV treatment publications, with hundreds of in-depth articles.

Published in the Bulletin of Experimental Treatments for AIDS October 1998 issue, by the San Francisco AIDS Foundation.

BETA
October 1998 Table of Contents

Main Page

Contact Us
beta@sfaf.org

Tuberculosis

Liz Highleyman

Tuberculosis (TB) is one of the most feared diseases known to humanity. An estimated one-third of the world's population is infected with TB. Although drugs began to bring the disease under control in the late 1940s, TB still kills more people worldwide than any other infectious disease.

TB infection is not the same as active TB disease. Nine out of ten people with healthy immune systems who are infected with TB bacteria do not develop active disease; this rate is 100 times higher in people with HIV. People with TB infection feel well, have no symptoms, and cannot spread TB to others. In some cases, however, the immune system can no longer control TB and active disease develops.


History

Humans have been plagued with TB since prehistoric times. Egyptian and Peruvian mummies have been found that show signs of TB. In 17th century Europe, most of the population was TB-infected and a quarter of deaths were attributable to the disease. The bacterium that causes TB was discovered by Robert Koch in 1882.

TB was previously known as consumption because people with the disease experienced slow wasting. Before the development of anti-TB drugs, people with TB were often sent to sanitoria to recuperate with fresh air, rest, and a healthy diet, and to prevent the transmission of the disease to others. In the pre-drug era, progressive TB disease was often fatal.

In the late 1800s, chest X-rays began to be used to monitor TB, and two French scientists developed an anti-TB vaccine known as Bacille Calmette-Guérin, or BCG. In 1944, streptomycin was the first antibiotic to be successfully used to treat a person with advanced TB disease. Soon, however, drug-resistant TB strains evolved, making clear the need for combination therapy.


Epidemiology

In the U.S., the rate of TB began to increase in the mid-1980s after declining for three decades. TB incidence increased 15% between 1984 and 1991. This increase has been attributed to a combination of HIV/AIDS, increased immigration, and the dismantling of the public health infrastructure. The resurgence served as a wake-up call, and health departments began devoting more resources to TB control.

Following a peak in 1992, the TB rate among U.S.-born persons has declined for five years. A total of 19,855 cases of active TB disease were reported in 1997 (a rate of 7.4 per 100,000 people). The rate of active disease in San Francisco is twice the California rate and four times the national rate. An estimated 10-15 million people in the U.S. are infected with TB but do not have active disease.

TB incidence continues to hold steady in foreign-born U.S. residents. Nearly 40% of TB-infected people in the U.S. are foreign-born, many of whom were infected in their countries of origin. The TB rate among foreign-born people is 4-5 times higher than that of U.S.-born people.

Globally, TB is most common in developing countries, especially in Africa, Asia, Latin America and, increasingly, in Eastern Europe. There are an estimated 8-10 million new cases of TB disease and three million deaths due to TB each year. The World Bank estimated in August that TB accounts for more than 25% of avoidable adult deaths worldwide. In March, the World Health Organization (WHO) reported that global efforts to control and eliminate TB are stalled in several countries.

TB incidence varies by race, age, and sex. People of color (including those born in the U.S.) have a higher risk than whites of becoming infected with TB and of developing active TB disease. The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimates that TB rates are ten times higher in Asians, eight times higher in African-Americans, and five times higher in Hispanics and Native Americans, compared to whites. Researchers think that different racial/ethnic groups may have varying genetic susceptibilities to TB, but the differences are also due to socioeconomic factors.

TB is more common in young children and the elderly, who tend to have weaker immune systems. Among middle-aged people, statistics indicate that women are more likely to develop active TB disease than men, possibly due to hormonal influences; development of active disease is also more likely during pregnancy.

Several medical and socioeconomic factors predict a higher risk of TB infection and disease, including diabetes, silicosis (a lung disease), chronic kidney failure, malnutrition, cancer chemotherapy, alcoholism, injection drug use, poverty, and residence in communal living settings such as homeless shelters, prisons, and long-term healthcare facilities.


Multidrug-Resistant TB

Beginning in 1990, epidemiologists began to see new strains of TB that were resistant to more than one of the drugs commonly used to treat the disease, usually isoniazid and rifampin. These strains are known as multidrug-resistant TB (MDRTB). Several outbreaks of MDRTB occurred in 1990-91 in hospitals and prisons in New York City and Florida. Many of the people affected were HIV positive.

MDRTB develops when the TB bacteria mutate in such a way that they lose their susceptibility to drugs. This is often caused by failure to take a full course of anti-TB treatment. The CDC reports that in 1997, over 7% of TB strains tested for drug susceptibility were resistant to at least isoniazid, and 1.3% were resistant to at least isoniazid and rifampin. MDRTB has been seen in over 40 U.S. states and 30 countries. The WHO recently reported on several MDRTB "hot zones" in countries including Russia, India, Argentina, and Côte d'Ivoire.

Treatment of MDRTB is typically longer and more expensive than treatment of drug-susceptible strains, and the fatality rate is higher. The development of multidrug-resistant strains points to the need for continual development of new anti-TB drugs.


Tuberculosis and HIV

The epidemics of TB and HIV are closely intertwined. HIV infection is among the strongest risk factors for the development of active TB disease. The HIV epidemic is increasingly affecting the same populations (people of color, the homeless, substance users, low income people) that have the highest rates of TB. And strategies for HIV treatment have increasingly come to resemble those established for the treatment of TB.

TB and HIV: Some Similarities in Treatment

  • Use a combination regimen of three, four, or more drugs
  • Monotherapy can rapidly lead to resistance
  • Do not add a single new drug to a failing regimen
  • Resistance testing can help guide therapy
  • Consult an expert in the case of treatment failure
  • Adherence is the key to successful therapy

Diane Bennett, MD, of the CDC, reported at the 12th World AIDS Conference in July that the U.S. rate of TB among people with HIV is more than 40 times greater than the rate in the general population. Worldwide, TB is the leading cause of death of people with HIV/AIDS. In 1993, TB was added to the CDC's list of AIDS-defining conditions. The rate of HIV in people with active TB disease is also high; in one recent study of 118 TB patients in Atlanta, over 40% had undiagnosed HIV infection.

In people previously infected with TB, HIV infection increases the risk of developing active TB disease by an estimated 100-fold. TB-infected HIV positive people have a 1 in 10 chance per year of developing active TB disease, compared to a 1 in 10 chance in a lifetime for TB-infected HIV negative people. People with HIV may experience a more rapid progression of TB disease; this is thought to be related to impaired T-cell activity. Several promising studies suggest that combination anti-HIV therapy (HAART) can lead to clinical improvement of TB disease in people co-infected with TB and HIV. A report presented at the July AIDS conference showed that HAART reduced the rate of TB disease by 50% in São Paolo, Brazil in 1997. TB also appears to accelerate the progression of HIV disease, possibly due to increased production of cytokines and the stimulation of HIV replication.

In addition, TB may manifest differently in HIV positive people. HIV-infected people are at higher risk for TB outside the lungs (extrapulmonary TB). Mary Reichler, MD, presented results of a study of over 7,000 people with TB and HIV at the July conference. She found that HIV positive people were almost twice as likely to have combined pulmonary/extrapulmonary TB as HIV negative people (55% vs 29%). She also found that HIV positive people were more likely to be infected with MDRTB. Other researchers at the conference reported increased occurrence of TB meningitis (infection of the membranes surrounding the brain) and TB pericarditis (heart infection) in people with HIV.

Fortunately, TB prevention and treatment of active TB disease using standard first-line regimens are effective in HIV positive as well as HIV negative people. In the past, many experts recommended a longer course of therapy for people with HIV, but recent trials have demonstrated that a shorter course of therapy is adequate in most cases. In general, the same drugs are used for HIV positive and HIV negative people; the exception is that people taking protease inhibitors should substitute rifabutin for rifampin (see section on drug side effects and interactions).


Pathogenesis of TB Disease

Tuberculosis is caused by Mycobacterium tuberculosis, a rod-shaped aerobic bacteria that is described as acid-fast because it remains stained when washed in an acid bath.

Primary infection is the initial entry of TB into the body. In most cases, TB remains inactive in the lungs. Reactivation, or recrudescence, occurs when the immune system can no longer keep TB under control. Active disease is most likely to develop within the first two years after infection.

After TB bacteria are inhaled, they settle in tiny air sacs deep in the lungs called alveoli. Here, the bacteria are engulfed by alveolar macrophages, a type of immune system white blood cell. As macrophages die, the released bacteria are engulfed by other immune system cells such as neutrophils and monocytes, which are called to the site by chemical messengers called cytokines. The body usually begins to mount a cell-mediated immune response within 2-4 weeks. This immune response depends on functioning T-cells, and is reduced in people with HIV.

Over time, the immune system walls off the TB bacteria in a defense structure called a tubercle or granuloma, which consists of a core of TB-containing giant cells surrounded by epithelioid cells, lymphocytes, and macrophages. Once the tubercle forms, the cells within it die, a process known as caseous necrosis. Tubercles may burst, releasing bacteria and leaving a hole or cavity in the lung. This process may eventually result in scars and calcium deposits which can harbor inactive bacteria and provide a source for later reactivation.

Immune cells containing TB bacteria may migrate to regional lymph nodes. If the immune system is too weak or the number of bacteria is too high, tubercle formulation may not adequately control the bacteria, which can enter the bloodstream, a condition known as disseminated TB. In miliary TB, infection becomes established at multiple locations throughout the body.

TB affects the lungs 85% of the time (pulmonary TB), but can affect almost any part of the body, including the liver and kidneys, the stomach and intestines, the bones, and the brain and spinal cord. Extrapulmonary TB is more common in children and people with weakened immune systems.

A person who has been infected with TB and received either preventive therapy or treatment for active disease can become infected again with a different TB strain, but this is uncommon since past infection does confer some protective immunity.


TB Symptoms

A person who has TB infection but not active disease typically does not have any symptoms. Symptoms of active TB disease in the lungs include a cough lasting longer than two weeks, expulsion of (possibly bloody) lung fluid, and chest pain. People with active TB disease in any part of their body may experience fatigue, weakness, malaise, loss of appetite, weight loss, and fever and/or chills (including night sweats). Untreated TB may lead to severe wasting and death.

If TB spreads through the bloodstream, a person may develop TB meningitis. Symptoms include headache, nausea, drowsiness, and eventually coma. TB in the lymph nodes can lead to inflammation and swelling called lymphadenitis. TB that infects the bone marrow may lead to anemia and other blood cell deficiencies. TB of the vertebrae is called Pott's disease, and may result in back pain and paralysis. Infants infected perinatally may have TB in multiple organs, with symptoms including respiratory distress, liver and spleen enlargement, and failure to thrive.

Several symptoms of TB disease are similar to those of other diseases such as HIV disease, toxoplasmosis, and Mycobacterium avium complex (a disease caused by a bacterium related to the one that causes TB). TB should be considered as a possibility when making a differential diagnosis.


Preventing TB Transmission

TB bacteria are spread from person to person through the air in droplets of sputum, which is fluid from deep within the lungs; transmission by ingestion or through a wound may occur, but is much less common. Droplets are carried through the air when a person with active TB disease coughs, sneezes, or spits. Droplets can remain suspended in the air for many hours, and TB bacteria can live in dried sputum for several days or weeks.

It usually takes an extended period of time for TB transmission to occur. Family members and others sharing a residence are most at risk. Occasional exposures to people with active TB disease usually do not lead to infection. The National Institutes of Allergy and Infectious Disease estimates that for people with healthy immune systems there is about a 50% chance of infection from spending eight hours a day over six months, or 24 hours a day over two months, with a person with active TB disease. Perinatal TB transmission from mother to fetus can occur, but it is more common for transmission to occur due to close contact between a TB-infected mother and her infant after birth.

A person who is TB-infected but does not have active disease usually cannot spread TB, and people who only have extrapulmonary (outside the lungs) TB are rarely infectious. Most people with active TB disease are no longer infectious after about three weeks of treatment.

Environmental Precautions

Precautions can be taken to prevent a person with active TB disease from transmitting the bacteria to others. People who are suspected of having or are being treated for active TB disease should be isolated from others until they are no longer infectious, and should cover their nose and mouth when they cough. Those who must be around people with active disease, such as healthcare workers, can use a disposable personal respirator (which resembles a surgical mask).

Engineering measures can remove or inactivate infectious bacteria. Isolation rooms should have a negative pressure, meaning that air tends to flow inward rather than outward. Proper ventilation mixes contaminated air and fresh air, thus reducing the number of infectious droplets; a ventilation system should vent contaminated air directly outside rather than recirculating it. High-efficiency particulate air (HEPA) filters can extract infectious droplets from the air, and ultraviolet light can kill TB bacteria.

TB Vaccines

The BCG vaccine, made from a weakened strain of Mycobacterium bovis -- a closely related bacteria that infects cattle -- is used in several countries for TB prevention, but is uncommon in the U.S. BCG is not highly effective in preventing TB, with estimates of efficacy ranging from 0-80%. The vaccine may, however, reduce the risk of serious complications due to TB. In the U.S., the CDC recommends BCG vaccination only for certain high-risk children. BCG should not be given to people with suppressed immune systems.

The mapping of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis genome, completed in 1997, offers new opportunities for genetically engineering a more effective vaccine. Several antigens of Mycobacterium tuberculosis have been identified that can stimulate an immune response. In the June 1998 issue of Infection and Immunity, researchers from Colorado State University, Merck and Company, and the Pasteur Institute reported on two vaccine candidates based on pieces of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis bacteria. The vaccines significantly lowered the risk of TB infection in animals, and the researchers are currently preparing to conduct human trials.

In late August, the federal Advisory Council for the Elimination of Tuberculosis issued a national call to develop an anti-TB vaccine. The organization recommends focusing on a post-infection vaccine that will prevent TB-infected people from developing active TB disease. The CDC has urged a "nationwide push" to develop a new vaccine, and predicts that several candidates should be available for human testing in the next few years.


Diagnosing TB

Skin Test for TB Infection

People who are infected with TB typically develop a hypersensitivity reaction which can be measured using a skin test called the Mantoux test. A small amount of a liquid purified protein derivative (PPD) of tuberculin is injected beneath the skin of the forearm. After 48-72 hours, a healthcare worker reads the test. A hard swelling (induration) at the injection site indicates that the person has been infected with TB. A swelling larger than 10 mm is considered a positive reaction for most at-risk people. For people with HIV or close contacts of people with active TB disease, a smaller cut-off of 5 mm is used.

It may take 10-12 weeks after infection before a hypersensitivity reaction develops, and a TB skin test may not be accurate during this "window period." People who have received the BCG vaccine may show a positive reaction on a TB skin test even if they are not TB-infected. This may also occur if a person is infected with a related species of mycobacteria such as Mycobacterium avium.

Some people with weakened immune systems do not produce a reaction when given a TB skin test, even if they are in fact infected. This condition is known as anergy. An anergy test uses control substances to measure cell-mediated immunity in order to determine whether a person is capable of mounting an immune response to common antigens. Anergy testing was once commonly used when skin-testing HIV positive people, and some experts still recommend it in individual cases; however, as of 1997 the CDC no longer recommends routine anergy testing for people with HIV.

Skin testing is recommended for people at risk of becoming infected with TB. Healthcare workers and others at risk of occupational exposure should be tested annually. HIV positive people should be tested when they are diagnosed with HIV, then annually thereafter. A conversion from a negative to a positive skin test indicates a recent infection. Skin test screening, in which large numbers of people are tested, is recommended for certain high-risk populations; screening of low-risk groups is not recommended by the CDC.

A positive TB skin test only indicates that a person has been infected with the TB bacteria; it does not mean that he or she has active TB disease.

Tests for Active TB Disease

Different tests are used to determine whether a person who has a positive skin test has active TB disease.

Chest X-rays are used to detect active disease and to gauge the extent of lung damage. People with active TB disease (or who have had active disease in the past) will typically show tubercles, cavities, and/or scars in their lungs. In people with HIV, however, chest X-rays are often atypical. Chest X-rays are not adequate to diagnose TB, but they may help rule out active disease.

A TB smear involves looking at a sample of sputum under a microscope to see if acid-fast bacteria are present. This type of test takes a few hours. The smear test cannot distinguish between TB and related species of mycobacteria such as Mycobacterium avium.

Culture tests are done to confirm that a person harbors active TB bacteria. In this test, a specimen of sputum (or another fluid such as urine, gastric juices, or cerebrospinal fluid in the case of extrapulmonary TB) is cultured in a laboratory. TB grows more slowly than most bacteria; it can take anywhere from 10-14 days to six weeks before bacterial growth is seen, depending on the culture medium used. More rapid tests that measure TB genetic material, including the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) test and the amplified Mycobacterium tuberculosis direct test (MTD), have recently been developed.

Regardless of what type of test is used for initial diagnosis, a culture is required for drug resistance testing. A test called restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) can identify specific TB strains, and is used to track transmission during outbreaks.


Treatment of TB

In most cases, TB can be successfully prevented or treated. Drugs can prevent the development of active disease in people already infected with TB, and can halt disease progression in people with active disease.

Preventive Therapy

People who have been infected with TB usually feel well, but are at risk for reactivation of TB as they age or if their immune system becomes weakened. Treatment of TB-infected people can prevent the development of active disease. Preventive therapy is recommended for at-risk people with positive TB skin tests; in certain cases, people at high risk of developing active TB disease may be given preventive therapy even if they do not have a positive skin test. Preventive therapy should not be given until the possibility of active TB disease has been ruled out.

The usual preventive therapy is isoniazid (INH), a well-tolerated and inexpensive drug. Isoniazid is typically taken daily or twice weekly for six months; nine months of therapy is recommended for children. Some experts recommend a longer course of therapy for people with HIV, but recent research suggests that six months is adequate in the majority of cases. Isoniazid is not known to cause fetal abnormalities, but still some experts recommend that TB-infected pregnant women without active disease should wait until after delivery to start preventive therapy. Isoniazid is highly effective; in various studies it has been shown to reduce the rate of active TB disease by 30-90% (depending on adherence). Side effects of isoniazid are discussed later.

Recent research suggests that a shorter course of preventive therapy may be as effective and easier to adhere to. Fred Gordin, MD, reported at the 5th Conference on Retroviruses and Opportunistic Infections in February 1998 that in 1,583 people co-infected with HIV and TB, a 2-month course of rifampin plus pyrazinamide was as effective in preventing active disease as a 12-month course of isoniazid alone (see Research Notes, BETA, April 1998).

An alternative preventive regimen is rifampin taken daily for 12 months, which is used if a person is suspected of being infected with an isoniazid-resistant strain of TB. If the TB strain is resistant to both isoniazid and rifampin, preventive therapy may be difficult. Possible regimens for MDRTB preventive therapy include pyrazinamide plus ethambutol daily for six months, and pyrazinamide plus ofloxacin or ciprofloxacin for six months.

Consistent adherence to the full prescribed preventive regimen is necessary to ensure that all TB bacteria are killed and that drug resistance does not develop. This is sometimes accomplished through directly observed therapy (described later). People should be monitored at least monthly while receiving therapy to ensure that it is working properly.

Treatment of Active TB Disease

Like HIV, TB bacteria can mutate rapidly to resist drugs, and effective treatment of active TB disease requires combination therapy. The standard first-line treatment for active TB disease is a 4-drug regimen that includes isoniazid, rifampin, and pyrazinamide, plus either ethambutol or streptomycin while drug resistance testing is being done; ethambutol is generally preferred because it is an oral drug, while streptomycin must be injected. If the TB strain is shown to be susceptible to isoniazid and rifampin, the ethambutol or streptomycin can be discontinued.

The currently favored short-course regimen involves an intensive 2-month, 4-drug induction phase followed by a continuation phase consisting of four additional months of just isoniazid plus rifampin. This regimen is highly effective in both HIV positive and HIV negative people. The same regimen is used for the treatment of extrapulmonary TB, although disseminated TB may require longer treatment.

The standard regimen may be modified to allow for intermittent rather than daily dosing, which can make directly observed therapy much more practical. Effective intermittent regimens include:

  • the standard 4-drug regimen daily for two months, then isoniazid plus rifampin two or three times per week for four months

  • the standard 4-drug regimen daily for two weeks, then the same four drugs two or three times per week for six weeks, then isoniazid plus rifampin two times per week for four months

  • the standard 4-drug regimen three times per week for six months.

Doses of isoniazid, pyrazinamide, and ethambutol should be increased if given two or three times per week rather than daily. An alternative regimen, if a person cannot take pyrazinamide, is a 9-month course of isoniazid plus rifampin.

The same standard 4-drug regimen is used to treat children with TB. However, in young children side effects may have to be managed differently, and ethambutol is not recommended. Isoniazid, rifampin, and ethambutol have not been shown to cause fetal damage and may be used by pregnant women. Streptomycin is not recommended for use during pregnancy because it can harm the fetus; pryazinamide has not been adequately tested for this indication. Pregnant women with active disease should be treated as soon as possible. The preferred regimen is isoniazid/rifampin/ethambutol for nine months.

Because TB was in decline for many years, minimal resources were devoted to developing new anti-TB drugs. Most of the drugs used today were developed in the 1950s and 1960s. In June, the FDA approved the first new TB drug in over 25 years. Rifapentine (brand name Priftin), made by Hoechst Marion Roussel, is a long-acting formulation of rifampin that can be taken twice weekly during the induction period and then once weekly for the continuation period.

Symptoms of active TB disease usually improve after 3-4 weeks of treatment, and most people are no longer infectious after about three weeks. A person is definitively considered to be non-infectious when they produce three negative sputum smears; smears typically become negative within 2-3 months. However, it is important that people continue to take their full prescribed course of drugs in order to kill all bacteria and to prevent a relapse or the development of drug resistance.

Regular follow-up (at least monthly) with sputum smears or cultures tests should be done to ensure that treatment is working. If a person still has symptoms or a positive culture after three months of treatment, drug resistance or nonadherence is likely, and re-evaluation and more extensive resistance testing should be done.

Treating Drug-Resistant TB

Treatment of drug-resistant TB is more difficult, takes longer and costs much more than treatment of drug-susceptible TB. In-hospital treatment for MDRTB may cost as much as $250,000. More drugs are required, they must be taken for longer periods, and they have more serious side effects.

TB strains are routinely tested for drug resistance. Use of the BACTEC system can determine resistance to the five most commonly used anti-TB drugs in about three weeks.

For TB strains that are resistant to isoniazid alone, the standard 4-drug regimen remains effective. If the TB strain is resistant to isoniazid and rifampin, at least three new drugs to which the TB strain is susceptible should be added, and treatment duration should be extended for up to 24 months. Sometimes seven or more drugs may be necessary. As is the case with combination anti-HIV therapy, a single drug should not be added to a failing regimen. It may be valuable to consult an expert when dealing with MDRTB.

Many drugs have been tried for TB treatment. The first-line drugs were chosen for their combination of tolerability and effectiveness. Some of the other drugs sometimes used are more toxic or must be given by injection. Others are in various stages of testing. The emergence of MDRTB has renewed the use of older drugs, encouraged the use of alternative drugs, and refocused efforts on the development of new drugs.

Drugs that may be tried as part of a combination regimen for MDRTB include aminoglycosides (e.g., amikacin, capreomycin, kanamycin), fluoroquinolones (e.g., ciprofloxacin, ofloxacin), cycloserine, ethionamide, clofazimine, and para-aminosalicylic acid. Rifamycin derivatives other than rifampin (for example, rifabutin) are also sometimes used. Macrolide antibiotics such as clarithromycin, which are effective against Mycobacterium avium, are not very active against Mycobacterium tuberculosis.

In some advanced, treatment-resistant cases of TB, surgery may be done. This involves removing part of the lung to excise the infected tissue. Sometimes corticosteroids are used to reduce inflammation and control tissue damage, especially when TB affects the brain.


Side Effects and Interactions of Anti-TB Drugs

The side effects of isoniazid are usually mild, and may include lack of appetite, nausea, vomiting, abdominal cramps, and central nervous system symptoms. The most worrisome side effect is liver toxicity leading to hepatitis. This is most likely in people over age 35 and those with existing liver damage. People should not drink alcohol when taking isoniazid, and liver enzyme levels should be monitored regularly. Another possible side effect is peripheral neuropathy, characterized by pain and tingling in the feet and hands. The risk of peripheral neuropathy may be reduced by using pyridoxine (vitamin B6) along with isoniazid.

Rifampin side effects include gastrointestinal upset, malaise, skin rash, sensitivity to sunlight and, less often, platelet deficiencies characterized by easy bleeding. The drug turns urine, tears, and saliva orange.

Because rifampin is metabolized by the CP450 enzyme system in the liver, it interacts with many other drugs that also use the same enzymes. This may result in undesirably high or low blood levels of the drugs. People on methadone maintenance taking rifampin often report withdrawal symptoms; this can be countered by increasing the methadone dose. Rifampin may make birth control pills and other hormonal contraceptives less effective.

The protease inhibitor drugs are also metabolized by the CP450 enzyme system. Taking rifampin and a protease inhibitor together may lead to subtherapeutic levels of the protease inhibitor and increased rifampin-related side effects (see Protease Inhibitor Drug Interactions, BETA, September 1997). If a person has not yet started combination anti-HIV therapy, some experts recommend waiting if possible until after TB treatment is completed.

If a person is taking a protease inhibitor, most experts recommend that they should not stop in order to take rifampin, as this could lead to the development of drug-resistant HIV. Instead, they should take rifabutin. This drug has anti-TB activity comparable to rifampin, but a lesser effect on the CP450 enzymes. Carol Dukes Hamilton, MD, of Duke University Medical Center, recommends that if a co-infected person requires both anti-TB treatment and protease inhibitor therapy, the best protease inhibitors to use are indinavir (Crixivan) or nelfinavir (Viracept), because they interact with rifabutin less than saquinavir (Fortovase) or ritonavir (Norvir). Doses of both rifabutin and the protease inhibitor may have to be adjusted. According to Vertex Pharmaceuticals, rifampin should not be used with amprenavir (Agenerase), and doses should be adjusted when combining rifabutin and amprenavir.

Among the other first-line drugs, pyrazinamide can lead to liver toxicity, gastrointestinal upset, joint pain, skin rash, and high blood levels of uric acid. The most serious side effect of ethambutol is damage to the optic nerve, which can lead to visual impairment and color blindness. Visual acuity should be checked regularly in people taking this drug, and it is not recommended for children too young to report visual changes. Streptomycin can cause damage to the inner ears, possibly leading to vertigo (dizziness and balance problems) and hearing loss. Auditory acuity should be monitored in people taking this drug, and it should be stopped if a person experiences ringing in the ears or any hearing loss. The aminoglycosides may also cause inner ear damage. Side effects of other drugs used to treat TB tend to be more serious, and these drugs are not favored except in cases of drug-resistant TB.


Major Drugs Used to Prevent and Treat Tuberculosis

 
Drug Name (Brand Name) Indication Primary Side Effects
isoniazid, a.k.a. INH (e.g.,

Duramed, Nydrazid)

first-line prevention therapy; part of first-line treatment combo hepatitis, peripheral neuropathy, mild CNS effects
Rifampin (Rifadin, Rifamate*, Rifater**) part of second-line prevention combo; part of first-line treatment combo GI upset, malaise, rash, hepatitis, orange urine/tears/saliva, light sensitivity, drug interactions
Pyrazinamide (e.g., Tebrazid) part of second-line prevention combo; part of first-line treatment combo GI upset, rash, joint pain, hepatitis, high uric acid levels, may cause fetal damage
ethambutol (Myambutol) part of prevention combo for MDRTB; may be part of first-line treatment combo (until isoniazid/rifampin resistance is ruled out) optic nerve damage (vision loss)
streptomycin may be part of first-line treatment combo (until isoniazid/rifampin resistance is ruled out) inner ear damage (hearing loss, vertigo), kidney toxicity, fetal damage
rifapentine (Priftin) long-acting form of rifampin (same indications) same as rifampin
rifabutin (Mycobutin) used instead of rifampin for TB treatment in people taking protease inhibitors GI upset, rash, eye inflammation (uveitis), neutropenia, orange urine/tears/saliva
amikacin (Amikin) may be tried in prevention and treatment combos, especially for MDRTB inner ear damage (hearing loss, vertigo), kidney toxicity, joint pain, may cause fetal damage
capreomycin (Capastat) may be tried in prevention and treatment combos, especially for MDRTB inner ear damage (hearing loss, vertigo), kidney toxicity, may cause fetal damage
kanamycin may be tried in prevention and treatment combos, especially for MDRTB inner ear damage (hearing loss, vertigo), kidney toxicity, may cause fetal damage
ciprofloxacin (Cipro) may be tried in prevention and treatment combos, especially for MDRTB nausea, diarrhea, abdominal cramps, rash, CNS effects, headache, convulsions, allergic reaction
ofloxacin (Floxin) may be tried in prevention and treatment combos, especially for MDRTB nausea, diarrhea, rash, insomnia, dizziness, CNS effects, headache, convulsions, allergic reaction
cycloserine (Seromycin) may be tried in prevention and treatment combos, especially for MDRTB CNS effects, dizziness, headache, depression, convulsions
ethionamide (Trecator) may be tried in prevention and treatment combos, especially for MDRTB GI upset, CNS effects, rash, loss of appetite, hepatitis
clofazimine (Lamprene) may be tried in prevention and treatment combos, especially for MDRTB GI upset including severe abdominal cramps, rash, eye irritation, discoloration of skin and body fluids
para-aminosalicylic may be tried in prevention and treatment combos, especially for MDRTB GI upset, liver toxicity, sodium acid level imbalance


GI: gastrointestinal
CNS: central nervous system
*Rifamate is a combination pill containing isoniazid and rifampin
**Rifater is a combination pill containing isoniazid, rifampin, and pyrazinamide


Ensuring Adherence

Given the length of TB prevention and treatment regimens, many people find it difficult to adhere to their anti-TB medication for the full period prescribed. Adherence may be improved by the use of short-course regimens, intermittent therapy taken 2-3 times per week rather than daily, combination pills such as Rifamate (rifampin/isoniazid) and Rifater (rifampin/isoniazid/pyrazinamide) which reduce the "pill burden," and long-acting drugs such as rifapentine which can be taken less often.

A system called directly observed therapy, or DOT, is often used to ensure that people with TB take their medication properly. A healthcare worker, family member, or community outreach worker watches to see that the person with TB takes his or her drugs as prescribed. DOT has been used increasingly in the U.S. since the 1970s and is recommended by the WHO. DOT is used for both preventive therapy and treatment of active TB disease. The system is labor intensive and requires a good public health infrastructure.

Many of the issues that have recently become apparent regarding adherence to anti-HIV therapy are familiar to those who treat people with TB. Patient education should emphasize the importance of complete treatment. Memory aids, incentives, and "enablers" (such as transportation and child-care) can help improve adherence.

Because of the infectious nature of TB and the public health implications of drug-resistant TB, sometimes more extreme measures are used, up to and including court-ordered involuntary confinement during treatment. Mandatory reporting, patient registries, and stringent contact tracing are also routinely used. Similar measures have been proposed for people with HIV/AIDS over the course of the epidemic, and are still being debated today.


Conclusion

The ups and downs of the TB epidemic over the past two decades -- and especially the development of multidrug-resistant TB strains -- have pointed to the need for a strong public health infrastructure and continued research and development of new TB treatments. In April, over 150 U.S. TB researchers and others urged President Clinton to increase funding for better diagnostic methods, more effective anti-TB drugs, and a more useful preventive vaccine.

Although environmental precautions and drug therapy can prevent active TB disease, many experts believe that only a vaccine can control TB globally. The effective drugs that now exist must be made more widely available worldwide, and drugs that allow for easier and shorter regimens are needed. The importance of good adherence and taking prevention and treatment regimens for the full prescribed length of time cannot be overemphasized.

In 1989, the U.S. set a goal to eliminate TB in this country by the year 2010. Given the increasing mobility of the world's populations, control of TB in the U.S. will require progress on a global level. According to Helene Gayle, MD, of the CDC, "As long as TB continues to threaten other nations, it will continue to threaten Americans."

Liz Highleyman is acting editor of BETA.

Thanks to Richard Mauery, MD, and Carol Dukes Hamilton, MD, for their helpful comments on this article.


American Thoracic Society/American Lung Association. Treatment of tuberculosis and tuberculosis infection in adults and children. American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine 149. January 1, 1994.

Bennett, D. and others. Double trouble: HIV/TB profiles from the U.S. and the U.K. derived from multiple surveillance systems. 12th World AIDS Conference. Geneva, Switzerland, June 28-July 3, 1998. Abstract 13268.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Tubercolusis morbidity -- United States, 1997. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 47(13). April 10, 1998.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Anergy skin testing and preventive therapy for HIV-infected persons: revised recommendations. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 46(RR-15). September 5, 1997.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Impact of HIV protease inhibitors on the treatment of HIV-infected tuberculosis patients with rifampin. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 45(42). October 25, 1996.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Management of persons exposed to multidrug-resistant tuberculosis. Document #250112. April 12, 1996.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Essential components of a tuberculosis prevention and control program/Screening for tuberculosis and tuberculosis infection in high-risk populations. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 44(RR-11). September 8, 1995.

Chaisson, R. and others. A randomized trial of rifampin/pyrazinamide for 2 months vs INH for 12 months in HIV+, tuberculin+ adults. 12th World AIDS Conference. Geneva, Switzerland, June 28-July 3, 1998. Abstract 447/22126.

Dukes Hamilton, C. Presentation at the 48th Annual TB/Respiratory Disease Institute. Black Mountain, NC. July 17-19, 1998.

Graham, N.M.H. and R.E. Chaisson. Tuberculosis and HIV infection: epidemiology, pathogenesis, and clinical aspects. Annals of Allergy 71: 421-428. November 1993.

Jamal, L.F. and other. Possible impact of antiretroviral therapy on the incidence of TB. 12th World AIDS Conference. Geneva, Switzerland, June 28-July 3, 1998. Abstract LB14373.

Reichler, M. and others. Epidemiology of extrapulmonary tuberculosis among HIV positive persons in the U.S., 1993-1996. 12th World AIDS Conference. Geneva, Switzerland, June 28-July 3, 1998. Abstract 13269.


Resources

American Thoracic Society of the American Lung Association

1740 Broadway, New York, NY 10019

American Thoracic Society: 212-315-8700

American Lung Association: 800-LUNG-USA

www.thoracic.org

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Division of Tuberculosis Elimination

404-639-8140 or 404-639-2519

www.cdc.gov/nchstp/tb

Website includes summary information about TB, links to TB-related articles, and the Core Curriculum on Tuberculosis.

Francis J. Curry National Tuberculosis Center

3180 18th Street, Suite 101, San Francisco, CA 94110

415-502-4600

www.nationaltbcenter.edu

National Jewish Medical and Research Center

1400 Jackson Street, Denver, CO 80206

800-222-LUNG or 800-652-9555

www.njc.org

New Jersey Medical School National Tuberculosis Center

65 Bergen Street, Newark, NJ 07107

800-4TB-DOCS

www.umdnj.edu/ntbc

U.S. Occupational Health ad Safety Administration

200 Constitution Avenue, Washington, DC 20210

www.osha-slc.gov/SLTC/tuberculosis

OSHA provides information about TB control and prevention of transmission.

World Health Organization Global Tuberculosis Programme

20 Avenue Appia, CH-1211, Geneva 27, Switzerland

41-22-791-2675

FightTB@who.ch

www.who.ch/gtb

Page last updated 6 October 1998


About AIDS | Treatment | Prevention | Policy | About SFAF | Take Action | Donate
Español | Search | Site Map | Feedback | Email Updates | Home (sfaf.org)